51 Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

17 minutes
October 24, 2022
Andi Gleeson

Any dessert buffet will have to give this exquisite pie first place. Make it for a special night or Thanksgiving with the family. The pie crust decorations give it a beautiful touch. A pie is a baked dish often wrapped in pastry dough and filled with a variety of sweet or savoury ingredients. In addition to being a wonderful source of fibre and vitamin E, they are also high in vitamin C and manganese. Fibre is crucial for helping you stay fuller for longer this holiday season if you’re trying to maintain a healthy weight. These Thanksgiving Pie Recipes will make your Thanksgiving celebration extra special.

1. Ginger Pumpkin Pie

Improve your favourite traditional pumpkin pie by adding more zingy ginger to it. Thanksgiving and other autumnal celebrations call for this ginger pumpkin pie.

2. Salted Caramel-Apple Slab Pie

Using pie dough that is ready to bake makes making apple pie simple! This simple slab pie that is guaranteed to please everyone has apples and salted caramel filling that is baked to taste and topped with a crumbly brown sugar-oatmeal streusel. You can create salted caramel cookies too.

3. Pecan, Hazelnut, and Coconut Tart

This traditional, extremely sweet sticky pecan dessert, has been transformed into a gluten-free, fructose-free, casein-free, and lactose-free beauty. In this delicacy, buttery chocolate shortbread crust is combined with coconut and nuts and baked until the top is glossy and crisp. It tastes somewhat like pecan pie and quite like a candy bar, which makes it ideal.

4. Nancy Fuller’s Double-Crust Apple-Cheddar Pie

Apple pie is always a pleasure and is a fantastic dessert to serve when the temperature begins to drop. Although apples are typically associated with fall, baking with them is not limited to this season. They are delectable all year long. You won’t ever get tired of eating apples because they have a wide variety.

5. Sweet-Potato Pie with Cornmeal Crust

There aren’t any major surprises in this Sweet Potato Pie with Cornmeal Crust, and it stays quite true to the original. With a dash of whole grain cornmeal in the crust to balance the velvety smooth filling, it substitutes coconut milk for sweetened condensed milk. You can create chocolate sweet potato chips too.

6. Pecan Slab PieMaple-Nut Pie

This extremely addictive maple pecan slab pie is the simple solution for making pies for a crowd this holiday season. The pie’s flaky crust and maple-pecan filling are sure to impress everyone. This Pecan Slab Pie has the best flavour and is a simple way to feed a crowd during Thanksgiving or any other special occasion because it is made with maple syrup, brown butter, and a hint of whiskey. A pie that is just as lovely and less stressful than a typical pie.

7. Maple-Nut Pie

This maple-sweetened walnut pie is loaded to the brim with finely chopped, fresh nuts that are baked into a custardy crust.

8. Rocky Road Pie

This Rocky Road Pie is a delectable treat made with rich chocolate pudding, marshmallows, and toasted almonds. It can be served chilled or frozen. Desserts that don’t require baking are wonderful, especially in the summer. The filling for the Rocky Road Pie is a creamy chocolate mixture with almonds and small marshmallows. Pour it on top of the crust, then follow it with more chocolate and whipped cream.

Read on: 10 Best Cool Whip Recipes

9. Pretzel-Chocolate-Pecan Slab Pie

This deliciously crunchy pie has some surprising undertones of orange, vanilla, and cinnamon, which are perfect contrasts to the salty pretzels. Feed a crowd with this large pretzel-covered pecan pie, which is filled with gooey chocolate chips.

10. Cranberry-Apple Hand Pies

Everyone’s favourite kind of pie is hand pies, which have a generous amount of flaky, buttery crust and mouthwatering-filled pockets. These flaky, golden cranberry apple hand pies have a jewel-toned, brandy-flavoured cranberry apple filling, however, bourbon, amaretto, or a dash of vanilla extract would all taste great.

11. Chocolate Coconut Pecan Pie

In this simple dish using handmade pie crust, the traditional pecan pie is given a coconut touch. All the gooey, nutty goodness of the original pie is present in this version, along with the sweetness of coconut and chocolate chips.

12. Bourbon-Pecan Pie

This pecan pie has a deeper, more subtle flavour than the traditional pecan pie since it is made with brown butter and bourbon. You won’t forget this bourbon pecan pie, I promise! In this simple recipe, bourbon replaces vanilla extract, giving a classic holiday treat a unique flavour.

13. Pumpkin Pie with Oat-Pecan Crust

It’s quick and simple to make this spiced oat crust, and it’s a wonderful change from a heavier pastry crust. Remove the pecans to further lighten the crust.

14. Cranberry-Cherry Cobbler Pie

The cherry pie gets a tartness boost from cranberries. This pie is easy to make thanks to canned fruit and refrigerated pie crusts. Surprisingly quick and simple to assemble, this cobbler. You don’t have to fuss with the crust, even though it might contain a few more ingredients than the pie. This cobbler is prepared similarly to most others by placing the batter on the bottom of the dish and topping it with a hot fruit filling.

15. Grape Slab Pie

A beautifully juicy, sweet, and tangy pie is grape pie. It has a lovely, deep purple hue and a texture akin to blueberry pie. The best time to eat this pie is when grapes are in season, which is often late summer to early fall. However, you may eat this pie all year long.

16. Mocha Cream Pie

A mocha pudding filling is placed inside a flaky blind baked pie crust for the Mocha Cream Pie with latte whipped cream. This pie is a coffee lover’s dream and is incredibly easy to make. For your next sweet treat, prepare this sumptuous mocha chocolate cream pie, which is composed of a crust made of crispy chocolate cookie pieces and thick and indulgent chocolate cream pudding tinged.

17. S’mores Galette

S’mores taste good in any configuration. Enjoy a fantastic summer by making this graham cracker-crusted S’mores Galette.

18. Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Fudge Pie

It’s hard to believe simply delicious this peanut butter fudge pie tastes. The dessert comprises a layer of fudge, peanut butter crumbles on top, and a delightful salted peanut butter caramel on the side.

19. Maple Granola Pecan Pie

This granola recipe, in their opinion, is the best. Delicious maple syrup, brown sugar, and roasted pecans are used to make it. As a result, this granola has a warm cinnamon flavour and is as sweet as pecan pie.

20. Pear, Date, and Sesame Pie

One of the best foods on the planet has to be pie. Pears are the perfect filling for pies tender and flaky, warm and cosy. Impress your guests with this pear-centred variation on the traditional apple pie! Beautiful to look at, great to eat, and quite easy to make.

21. Banana Tart Tatin

If you’re in the mood for something sweet, sticky, and brown, try making this salted caramel banana tarte Tatin with pecans. The ideal treat for a weekend at home is sweet bananas with salty caramel and buttery pecans, but it’s not for the faint of heart! To vary the level of labour, you can either create your puff pastry or buy pre-rolled puff dough. In either case, this tart made of banana puff pastry will rank among the nicest desserts ever.

22. Lemon-Buttermilk Tart

A fresh take on a custard tart that is luscious but held in check by the acidity of the buttermilk and lemons. If the weather is warm, think about rolling out the pastry between two sheets of baking paper, and chilling it again just before lining the pan. The traditional Thanksgiving desserts are a great alternative to this lemon tart.

23. Old-Fashioned Pecan Pie

There is no corn syrup in this traditional pie. As the pie bakes, the nuts on top toast well and match the creaminess of the browned pecans bottom. The filling is silky smooth. Light corn syrup, which is almost flavourless and enables the nuttiness of the pecans to show, is called for in the filling. Its richer flavour and darker hue.

24. Decadent Chocolate-Espresso Pie

A chocolate lover’s paradise, this lavish Espresso Chocolate Pudding Pie! This recipe is always a hit with guests due to its chocolate cookie dough, super smooth espresso chocolate pudding, and a rich top of freshly whipped cream. It’s an easy recipe that you can prepare now. For a presentation that steals the show, add chocolate curls on top.

25. Pear Crumb Pie

The best crumble pie is caramel pear crumble pie! This pie is a must-bake for Thanksgiving because of its flaky all-butter crust, deliciously spiced caramel-pear filling, and golden crumble topping. It’s very simple and quick to make this traditional pear pie! Season the freshly picked, juicy pears with butter and brown sugar crumble on top with nutmeg and cinnamon.

26. Cheddar Apple Pie

A buttery cheddar cheese pie crust and a rich, molten, cinnamon apple filling are combined in this apple cheddar pie. Each slice of the extremely flaky cheddar pie is mostly sweet, slightly salty, and completely fulfilling. This recipe is unquestionably the one to try if you’re looking for an improvement to classic apple pie.

27. All-American Apple Pie

This recipe for handmade apple pie blends sweet and sour apples with a flaky buttery crust. you may serve this dessert at almost any event. This dish is a favourite in the household. With a fantastic non-crust topping, it’s quick and simple. Try several kinds of apples and mix them up.

28. Buttermilk Pie with Pecan Crust

The buttermilk Pecan Pie Recipe is comparable to a typical pecan pie, it’s simply creamier, and the new mild tang from the buttermilk is amazing. So, the Buttermilk Pecan Pie Recipe is just as sweet and nutty as the pecan pies you adore, but it’s creamier and with a lovely tang. The sweetness and nuttiness are also identical to the pecan pies you’ve come to love. Desserts are truly a staple of the American South.

29. Pumpkin Pie with Autumn Leaves

This Fall Leaf Pumpkin Pie will make you fall in love with dessert. This straightforward and lovely pumpkin pie, which has a pie crust decorated with multicoloured leaves, is ideal for Thanksgiving or any other autumn celebration. Traditional pumpkin pie recipe with the homemade buttery crust: the rich, silky, creamy, spiced type we are all familiar with.

30. Rustic Apple Galette with Butterscotch Sauce

¬†It’s similar to apple pie, but better because it contains delicious layers of baked apple in a simple tart crust. The ideal Fall dessert dish is a delectable galette French apple tart, which can be made in under an hour. This recipe for a rustic apple galette is perfect in every aspect; it features a buttery, flaky crust and luscious apples that have been sprinkled with cinnamon. Served with mouth-melting vanilla bean ice cream and zesty caramel sauce.

31. Sweet Potato Pie With Walnut Topping

One of the best Thanksgiving desserts is sweet potato pie, a genuine classic that fits on every holiday table. The walnut topping gives this homemade sweet potato pie the ideal crunch, and it is easy to make, delicious, and flavorful. For your festive season dessert, discover how to make sweet potato pie.

32. Chocolate-Pecan Tartlets

This is a classy take on traditional pecan. The rich flavour of the heated pie is enhanced by a sprinkle of bourbon. One large tart or eight small tarts can be made using this recipe for chocolate pecan tarts. These pecan tartlets have tart shells filled with gooey filling, bittersweet chocolate, and pecan halves.

33. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Sour Cream-Sweet Potato Pie

Switch to sweet potatoes instead of pumpkin because they have a richer taste and are more nutrient-rich. Sour cream is used in this Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie recipe to make a luxuriously smooth texture. This time-honoured method gave the dish a particularly rich and velvety-smooth texture while also helping to balance the flavours. You will adore it.

34. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Pumpkin Meringue Pie

The simple meringue topping gives this pumpkin pie a lot of curb appeal. Whip the whites until they retain stiff, silky tops for the ideal texture, but leave the mixture spreadable enough that you can add decorative swirls as you top the pie. It’s best to make the baked pie the day before you need it because it needs at least 6 hours to chill.

35. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Apple Crumb Cheesecake Pie

A layer of cheesecake, fresh apple pie filling, and an oatmeal crumb topping are used to make this Apple Crumb Cheesecake Pie. It’s a delightful dessert idea with an excellent blending of flavours and textures! This cheesecake with apple crumbles screams fall baking effort. A crisp cinnamon graham cracker crust and a smooth brown sugar cheesecake filling are the basis of the cheesecake.

36. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Pecan Streusel Pumpkin Pie

A tasty sweet pecan streusel tops this easy-to-make pumpkin pie. This one has a pecan streusel that is delightfully crunchy on top. The pumpkin filling has a taste of spices and sweetened condensed milk. If you’re craving pumpkin at any time of year, this dish is a great treat to serve during fall or winter events.

37. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Dulce de Leche Pumpkin Pie

The dulce de leche’s unique flavour  However, it provides the pie with a soothing touch of caramelised sugar and a base of flavour that is typically lacking in most classic pumpkin pies. Since the dish itself is not very sweet, the sweetened whip cream that it merges with supports the pie’s maximum freshness.

38. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Skillet Caramel Apple Pie

Your family’s favourite fall pie will be the skillet caramel apple pie. The apple is the ideal fruit for fall, specifically with a dash of cinnamon or a dusting of sugar. It is the ideal size to not have too many leftovers to clean up, and this little cast iron skillet apple pie is incredibly delicious! The delicious caramel topping fulfils the pie’s flavour profile and only serves to raise it to the level of the best caramel apple pie.

39. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Foolproof Cherry Pie

You’ll want to make this foolproof cherry pie all season long because it’s sweet and refreshing. It goes so well with a cup of coffee! For you and your family, it’s the ideal recipe for homemade cherry pie.

40. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Caramel Pear Pie

The amazing buttery/silky texture of pears combines well with a flaky, crisp pie crust. The pears in the pie have a tender-crisp texture after baking and cooling. This pear pie is a great alternative to traditional apple pie. It is made with a flaky, buttery pie crust and is filled with delicious pears and gooey caramel sauce. It is simple to prepare and ideal for the holiday season.

41. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Chai Pumpkin Pie With Maple Whipped Cream

A piece of Chai Pumpkin Pie with Maple Whipped Cream is enjoyed. This pie can be made the day before and chilled the following day. It is better to make the whipped cream right before serving, though.

42. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Snickerdoodle Pie

Snickerdoodle pie that is warm and delicious with extra cream cheese icing on top! It is lovely and kind. The ideal, buttery crust. Snickerdoodle Pie is a comfort meal. The bottom of this tender cake pie, which is based on a classic cookie recipe, is baked with cinnamon-sugar syrup.

43. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Nutella Dulce de Leche Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

The Nutella Dulce De Leche Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie has a fluffy, creamy pie crust, a delicious layer of dulce de leche and Nutella, and, to top it all off, melting chocolate chip cookie dough.

44. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Brown Butter Maple Chess Pie

This brown butter bourbon chess pie is one of the most loved simple desserts! It contains a thick custardy filling with a flaky, buttery pie crust! It’s easy to make and delicious to boot! To finish it off, just a dollop of handmade whipped cream will do.

45. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Deep Dish French Silk Pie with Hazelnut Oreo Cookie Crust

The most amazing hazelnut oreo cookie crust and whipped cream have made this french silk pie the Tastiest ever. For birthdays or special occasions, make this rich, delicious deep-dish french silk pie recipe.

46. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Toffee Almond Pie

Toffee Nut Pie has a lot of pecans and almonds that are crispy and gooey. It has a lot more flavour than pecan pie, though. This pie’s flavour is far more unique and delectable than a plain pecan pie because it contains both almonds and pecans. It is simply amazing how the gooey, sweet filling contrasts with the crunch of the nuts. This toffee nut pie is quite simple to make, much like a pecan pie. The toffee pieces melt and enhance the butterscotch flavour.

47. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Apple and Cranberry Hand Pies

This recipe’s¬†favourite kind of pie is hand pies, which have a generous amount of flaky, buttery top and mouthwatering-filled pockets. These flaky, golden cranberry apple hand pies have a jewel-toned, brandy-flavoured cranberry apple filling, however, bourbon, amaretto, or a dash of vanilla extract would all taste great.

48. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Apple Pie With Cheddar Thyme Crust

The top of the cheddar in this crust gets deliciously sprinkled and toasted while the inside gets rich and creamy while baking. A small amount of thyme is added to the filling, along with traditional spices like nutmeg and cloves. It’s just so refreshing to have days with fresh air, sunshine, clear skies, and temperatures that are still warm.

49. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Gingersnap Pumpkin Pie

This gingersnap pumpkin pie recipe is the greatest because it combines a sweet and spicy gingersnap cookie crust with a silky smooth, robustly spiced, and incredibly flavorful pumpkin inside. It will undoubtedly become a Christmas family favourite as well as gluten-free.

50. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Adorable Turkey Crust Pumpkin Pie

This holiday season, your family and friends will be amazed by this lovely turkey-crust pumpkin pie that is simple to make. Let me demonstrate how simple it is to put this tasty Thanksgiving holiday dish together and bake it.

51. Thanksgiving Pie Recipes – Mini Pumpkin Pies

Making mini pumpkin pies in a muffin tin for a small Thanksgiving gathering. A two-person Thanksgiving dinner would be ideal for this two-bite pumpkin pie recipe. You can sprinkle whipped cream and additional pumpkin pie spice over top.


A lovely time of year is Thanksgiving when the entire family gathers to express gratitude for everything they have. Given how crucial food is to this holiday, it is entirely acceptable to go overboard when planning your Thanksgiving buffet.

Try one of the pies on this list if you want to shake things up this year when choosing dessert. Since there is never too much food for Thanksgiving, you can still bake the traditional pumpkin pie.

Andi Gleeson, food blogger

Andi Gleeson

Andi Gleeson is a passionate blogger and mom based in San Francisco who focuses on easy and delicious dinner recipes.

Leave a Reply

Your rating

Related Recipes